Game Music, Reviews

Appetizing Apotheosis: Go Shiina Takes on the Gods — God Eater OST (Review)

April 12, 2010 | | 6 Comments Share thison Facebook Appetizing Apotheosis: Go Shiina Takes on the Gods — God Eater OST (Review)on Twitter

Namco Bandai is really good at copying ideas*. Whether it’s Tekken chasing Virtua Fighter’s tail and then giving it a good chomping or Soul Edge teaching SNK’s Samurai Spirits what weapon-based fighting looks like in three dimensions, it’s fair to say that quite a few of Namco Bandai’s hits borrow liberally from other sources. But to be even more fair, ‘is really good at copying’ might as well be ‘improves upon’. Both Tekken and the Soul Series developed a depth not matched by their rivals – in narrative, character development and, of course, music. So when Namco Bandai took a stab at the wildly popular Monster Hunter model, announced Sakamoto Maaya as one of the voice actors and gave the role of scoring to Go Shiina, it was almost a given that God Eater would devour the PSP market whole.

Okay, that was the last ‘eating’ pun. I promise. Because what you really want to read is whether or not Shiina, who hasn’t carried a full-scale soundtrack on his own since Tales of Legendia, is up to the task. No single person has scored a Soul game or a Tekken, and even some of the greatest Final Fantasy soundtracks have had their share of composition delegation.

We analyze just how far one man can push the sonic boundaries after the jump.

My first exposure to Masaru ‘Go’ Shiina was in 2007, when I heard several themes from his excellent Tales of Legendia performed live, and my first impression upon meeting him afterwards was ‘that’s some funky hair’. But I knew by then this soft-spoken newcomer would sooner or later receive the chance to really flex his composing muscles.

Firstly, the theme song: “Over the Clouds” by aLan. Not Shiina’s composition, but I’ve been a fan of aLan since her contribution to the Red Cliff films. Actually, I’m a fan of J-pop game intros in general, so this energetic start worked just fine for me. The same goes for the other ‘vocal tracks’ of the game, but more on them in a bit.

I believe that an equilibrium between distinct style and diverse range is a hallmark of greatness, and Shiina’s introductory track illustrates this perfectly. Take the very best of Legendia’s thematic elements, push them even further with frenetic piano (quite reminiscent of Tekken 5 Dark Ressurection’s “Sunrise”) add heavier percussion and you’re “Tearing up a Storm”. “The Howl of the Wolf” builds on this with punchy brass and background choir, but it’s  “A Shadow Covering the Town”, another frantic theme,  that foreshadows the game’s most well-known theme, thanks to a pre-release sample on the website.

A mere snippet of “An Approaching Nightmare” sold me on this OST. Two versions feature on the album and, unsurprisingly, they’re both spectacular. The first is primarily acoustic, but it’s the latter to which I keep returning. Despite the ubiquity, I still dig a good chorus, but if you really want to tingle and titillate my hearingbuds (as opposed to tastebuds), mesh voice and machine – and I don’t mean auto-tune, although there are some interesting applications of that on the album too. The carefully-processed chorus of “Nightmare” is something Shiina experimented with on Legendia but here, as child-like chanting in refreshing, powerful triplets  fuses with rock and blazing strings, we have something instantly unique and catchy. If facing down Shiva or Kali had a theme, this would be it.

A brief note about “Voice of the Blizzard” – I love, and I mean seriously love, synth panpipe, and I haven’t heard it used this brazenly in a game since a little-known RPG for the SNES called Arcana, a.k.a. Cardmaster (an early composition from Jun Ishikawa and Hirokazu Ando). Love. Muuuch love.

There’s another battle theme I want to highlight, because it really shouldn’t work but still sorta does. That auto-tune I mentioned? Give it some fairly uncreative synth backing, lyrics that probably sound more profound if you don’t understand English and a light choir backing. Call it something bland like “No Way Back –Out of My Way-” and then try to hate yourself as you unconsciously nod your head to the beat despite all logic. Oh, and if the auto-tune is a bit much for you, there’s another version on there with Ben Franklin’s clean voice in a more straightforward rock rendition.

More familiar is the presence of Donna Burke, who has lent her talent to the likes of Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles, Tales of Legendia and Kanno Yoko’s Turn A Gundam. Here she drives Shiina’s expansion of the short but poignant piano and cello piece “God and Man” to some beautiful heights and tempestuous turmoil with full orchestral accompaniment, reminding us that Shiina also created some of the most moving [email protected] songs. Again, the lyrics aren’t exactly poetic genius, but Donna’s voice more than compensates.

The scope doesn’t stop at surging battle themes, sweeping thematic developments, rock songs and orchestral ballads, either. Shiina has scored an entire world and it sounds like he explored one to bring it all together. There’s the jazziness of “Adult Time”, the almost 80s electricity of  “Fury”, a flamenco-tinged “Flame Dance” and, one of my favorites, the bluesy down-home sway of “A Person’s Warmth”. Another treat is “Ephemeral Wish”, which starts with organ and flute, transitions into piano heard through a crackly radio or phonograph, and then becomes ‘live’ with strings and percussion, and finally brass for a full-bodied crescendo. And I do hope auto-tune doesn’t automatically deter you, because “Enemies of Mankind” and “Table of the Gods” both revel in it, with the latter combining Indian classical undertones, orchestra, synth sampling and tuned female chanting to create a sort of Hindustani electronica dance hymn. Did we mention Shiina likes to blend things?

And just to prove he’s not above more traditional epic choir, Shiina presents “Deo Volente,” which weighs in at a compact two minutes and yet, regarding your typical end-boss theme, has it all in proper proportions. The chorus never dominates, the string melodies never get dull and the soundtrack’s flavor is never compromised or left behind. That Shiina could fit such a stock-standard style ‘big bad’ tune into this ever-surprising album and have it hold its own speaks volumes of his ability to shape not only great tracks but a truly great score overall.

There is also a 17 minute mini-drama which may or may not be of much interest to you, depending on your Japanese proficiency or, as in my case, high-school level Japanese feeding  a quietly rabid adoration of Sakamoto Maaya. (Okay, so I lied about the puns.)

In lesser hands, all this genre-hopping would be imbalanced and experimental, mediocrity spiked with moments of goodness. But, as is my habit when I want to make very clear how highly I think of someone, I’m going to place Go Shiina on the same top shelf in terms of one-man (or woman) master-craftsmanship as a few names you might recognize as ‘gods’ of the field: Yasunori Mitsuda, Yuki Kajiura, and yes, Nobuo Uematsu. I’ve missed one particular name, but that’s because I intend to rock the boat a little. We at OSV loved Hamauzu’s Final Fantasy XIII 4-disc behemoth but I personally prefer the God Eater soundtrack, and given that FFXIII had two other prominent composers (with Ryo Yamazaki crafting a good number of my favourite XIII tracks), not even the mighty XIII sits in the same one-man musical tour-de-force category as God Eater. With that statement, I have no choice but to submit that Go Shiina is, by possibly a tiny margin, currently my favorite active RPG composer – not bad for a dude who only has one other RPG under his belt. I won’t hesitate to recommend you hit Play-Asia and grab a copy of this album post-haste.

Dear Namco Bandai: give this man more work already.


*But not necessarily as good with blending them: yeah, I’m looking at you, Ehrgeiz.

Tags: , , , , ,


We like it when you talk to us

Add your comment below and subscribe to this conversation here. Spam will be moderated.



Make it fancy?

« Next Post

Previous Post »

More like this Post